A jewel beyond price

2011 is the 650th anniversary of the office of Justice of the Peace.

Most people will be only dimly aware that over 95% of the judicial work in the courts of this country is carried out by unpaid volunteers who have taken an oath that they “will well and truly serve” the Queen “in the office of Justice of the Peace and do right to all manner of people after the laws and usages of the Realm without fear or favour, affection or ill will.”

“Justices of the Peace” have in fact been around for even longer than that! After trial by ordeal, with its illogical outcomes of innocence only being presumed after the accused had succumbed to the ordeal by fire or ducking stool and survival of the ordeal meaning guilt, there was a period when offenders appeared before their villages or local communities where innocence depended on the number of “oath bearers” or “jurors” an alleged miscreant could muster. If he could muster more than his accusers, he was innocent. Better than trial by ordeal but still far from perfect!

Continue reading

Battle of the e-discovery bulge

In the last winter of the Second World War (1944-5), the Germans and the Allies fought a tank battle in the Ardennes region of France which has become known as the Battle of the Bulge, so called because of the initial German advance which caused a bulge in the Allied line as depicted in maps and newspaper reports of the time.

It was one of the bloodiest battles of the war. Official estimates put American dead at 19000 with over 80000 casualties, and German casualties were said to be between 60000 and 100000.

Dramatised in the 1965 film Battle of the Bulge starring Henry Fonda, Robert Shaw, Telly Savalas, Dana Andrews and Charles Bronson, the allied victory marked the beginning of the end of the German war effort as their reserves had been depleted and the Luftwaffe smashed.

Continue reading

No tea party

“Listen my children and you shall hear
Of the midnight ride of Paul Revere..”

Paul Revere’s ride, as retold in Longfellow’s poem, together with the Boston Tea Party are two of the iconic events leading up to the American War of Independence. On April 18th 1775, Paul Revere set off to ride to Lexington, Massachusetts to warn of the approach of British troops intent on the arrest of Samuel Adams and John Hancock. Sixteen months earlier, in December 1773, the destruction of tea at Boston harbour became a turning point in the struggle for independence of the United States from Britain. Known subsequently as the Boston Tea Party, a group of men had boarded three ships carrying taxed tea to Britain and destroyed the tea by throwing it into the harbour.

These days the Tea Party has other connotations but my reasons for being in Boston this week are professional rather than political.

Continue reading

No magic roundabout

We have all heard about Silicon Valley and some of us have even heard about Silicon Fen (the area around Cambridge which is home to many dotcom and other technology start ups) and a few will even have heard of New York’s Silicon Alley!

However, just when you thought you were safe, along comes the Silicon Roundabout, the name given to the booming Old Street/Shoreditch area on the northern edge of the City of London.

Roundabouts are becoming somewhat of a recurring theme in this blog (it is only a few weeks since I was singing the praises of Nashville’s Music Row roundabout) but this roundabout doesn’t yet have the same cachet, sitting as it does in the middle of the busy intersection of Old Street and City Road, and above the entrance to the underground station.

I have worked in the area for some years now and I must confess I have never thought of it as a particularly noteworthy or pioneering area. Indeed, it could be said that after many years of upgrading the Tube, there is one station which really needs a make over, and that is Old Street.

Continue reading

Lost for words

On the flyleaf of a book given to me by a friend appear the words “…I hope this book brings on an afflatus rather than a Winchester Goose….”

If you are anything like me, you will not immediately understand where the donor is coming from. Indeed, I had to look up the words in the very same book (The Superior Person’s Book of Words by Peter Bowler, first published in Great Britain by Bloomsbury in 2002) before I got the joke.

If you want to know the meaning of zzxjoanw, nepheligenous or thaumaturge you will need to refer to Mr Bowler’s entertaining book, available on Amazon and in good bookshops everywhere. I know what you will be thinking! He has lost his marbles, spent too much time overindulging or is suffering from sunstroke (on the Sussex coast, in October?) The weather was blistering but…

Continue reading

Finding the missing link

I promised to return to the subject of the missing link at the end of my last post when I said that:

“I will try and explain what I think he (Richard Susskind) meant and how this ties up with new legal structures, technology, LPOs and dead satellites falling to earth in my next post.”

I was a litigation lawyer for many years and with all the benefit of hindsight and from the privileged position of no longer having to earn my living by being a litigator I occasionally pause to reflect on where the litigation process and litigation lawyers are going. I worry when I see a profession that is unable to find jobs for bright graduates of the LPC. They would be of huge benefit to their chosen profession, if only they could be selected for a training contract to help them pay down the debt they incurred to get themselves through university and the professional exams now demanded of them.

Continue reading

In search of the missing link

Earthquake in Indonesia: thousands die, no Britons involved

This kind of laconic if self-centered headline has always amused me. We tend to think things are important if they affect us and less so if they do not. On that basis I wonder if we should have been concerned about the recent report from NASA that preceded one of its satellites falling to earth. The agency did not know when or where the satellite would drop but in order to assuage the fears of the populace at large said that it will be somewhere between Alaska and the tip of Southern America, it would be in late September but could be in October and, doubtless, we were all pleased to learn that there was only a one in 3,200 chance of satellite parts hitting anyone.

If ever there was a piece of more useless headline information, I have yet to see it. Presumably, the inhabitants of the whole continent of America would have been taking precautions for an event that had a real chance of catastrophe. After all, a one in 3,200 chance spread amongst about 500 million people is still a 0.000006 chance that someone might suffer from a severe headache when hit by part of the stray satellite falling out of the night sky, clobbering them on their way to work.

Continue reading

Roundabout ways

One of the most striking sights in Nashville, Tennessee is Alan LeQuire’s bronze statue of nine nude figures in the centre of the Music Row roundabout. Apparently the statue caused a certain amount of unease amongst the locals when it was unveiled in 2003 but it is certainly dramatic to view at night especially after making the acquaintance of too many Confederate Widows.

I should explain. Apart from a lot of walking the halls at ILTA in Nashville last month there was time for a couple of outings, one to Jimmy Kelly’s, a wonderful steak restaurant followed by drinks at what GQ magazine has described as the best bar in America, the Patterson House. While there I was persuaded to try a mixture of gin, lime, honey syrup and Pernod – a drink which goes by the extraordinary name of “Oldest Confederate Widow”.

Continue reading

Blurt outed

Sarah Vine is a journalist at The Times.

She is also Mrs Michael Gove, wife of the Education Secretary.

Normally I would find it difficult to justify blogging about the wife of a politician who, as far as I am aware, has absolutely nothing to do with, and quite possibly no interest in, the world of e-discovery.

However, it so happens that The Times of September 21st published an article written by Education Editor Greg Hurst entitled “Gove intrigue over ‘official use of private e-mails’.” In his piece Mr Hurst refers to a controversy which has arisen over the Education Secretary’s relations with his civil servants, some of whom appear to have been bypassed as a result of the alleged use of private emails by the department’s special advisers and possibly also by Mr Gove himself.

Continue reading

Storm clouds

Storm CloudsGlobal warming and/or climate change are not the staple of this blog. That is not about to change but I have to say that what others call the extremes of climate (and we in the UK just call “the weather”) has been much in my mind recently.

I suppose it all started with what by any standards has been the almost continuously poor weather throughout what passes for summer in these islands, made all the worse by the spectacular spring when the sun shone almost unceasingly and the temperature over Easter was in the 80s, with the promise of more to come. It was around then that people started saying they feared for the harvest because of the lack of rain. As I was not trying to grow anything organic, I felt that the doomsayers ought to be careful what they wished for and sure enough once the rain and cool weather arrived no one seemed to know how to turn it off! And, surprise, surprise, the harvest has not been all that bad overall. We have just had yet another disappointing summer.

Continue reading